Score: 5

"poor effort"

submission: Kanye West: Hurricane

date: October 3, 2005

I loved the Naruto cosplayers in front of White Castle...

BUT

Since you very likely diddnt take that picture, i'd have to say this was pretty poor. It would be one thing if either the argument was funnier, or the animation was better, but it was a rather juvenile stab (not to say that i don't agree with how wrong Kanye was, i agree 100%) the jokes were just basic and un-funny. And the character was very poorly designed. Not to mention your lip-sync. It's one thing to do an anime flapping mouth lip sync, it may be cheap, but its consistant; but don't put random mouth states cycling through speech. That just shows carelessness on your part.
JPEG stuff is old and tired, and this hit a little late considering the proximity of the event to now. Better luck next time.

Score: 6

"hehe"

submission: My friend the pigeon

date: September 15, 2005

Not bad at all. Would loved SOME sound, like old fashioned ragtime in the background but hey, i can understand the technical difficulty. Tighten your style and add some length and you have some promise m'friend!

Score: 4

"What?"

submission: Mean Shepherds - Part#4

date: September 15, 2005

I don't really get it. Other than the nice illustrated background, this was a poor effort. Blam it!

Score: 7

"Nice!"

submission: Porno Creep

date: September 5, 2005

I can't seem to understand how sprite animations and video game parodies break the 4 point rating barrier no problem, but some nice key framed goodness is doomed in the 3 zone. Be that as it may this was quite refreshing to see something so original on the front page. Good job guy!

Score: 3

"Stop"

submission: S.M.B.2 Bloopers

date: September 5, 2005

Good job you know how to do sprite animation. Congradulations. Do something more productive with your time. This was pretty bad i must say. I managed to watch the entire thing without laughing. Fart jokes and sprite sex... this was way ahead of its time.

Score: 10

"Amazing"

submission: Cigarette

date: August 7, 2005

That song was always something very moving to me, but with the beautiful animation and flawless artwork, it drove it right home for me. This animation was superb. I really hope to see more from you sir.

Score: 8

"Solid!"

submission: Talon VS Salocin - Part 1

date: July 23, 2005

It does my heart good to see that when a young animator decides "okay, i'm going to make a flash with some fighting in it" that they do it in the best way possible. I thought i saw where this was going, but the last 10 seconds or so were quite a visual feast. You have a great handle on timing and perspective, as well as the character rotations. The camera angles were handled beautifully. Over all very well composited!! Hope to see even more in the next episode!

Score: 8

"solid"

submission: Angrybot 2 - Recess

date: July 21, 2005

Hah! Dumpster detention. Not bad at all. Good use of robot...

Score: 7

"Meh"

submission: Patience

date: July 21, 2005

Not bad. You set it up rather well, and it was very nicely drawn. However, it was terribly anti-climactic. There seemed to be no real point beyond the trite exaggeration of a quote that you wanted to fulfill graphically. Next time, give us a bit more substance.

Score: 10

"Put cho fist up!"

submission: N.Swiler's Poison Dove

date: July 17, 2005

My fist and i relished the sight of this animation... with relish.